Skip to content

Shootout #5Results in

Holiday gift return policies: Amazon, Walmart, Target, Best Buy, Costco

A $300 laptop, bought in November 2026 as a gift, that might come back in mid-January 2027. Four agents scored, same prompt, Nov 10, 2026. Ranked by points, then items met, then fewest factual errors, then time. Every scored run cost $0 extra. No business was contacted, no account was created, and nothing was bought. Grok (Heavy) passed 8/8 with 0 factual errors in about 1 minute. That is Grok’s first win. ChatGPT’s first attempt was aborted because the prompt was split into separate messages; the clean rerun is the scored run. Manus returned a connection error and no answer. Lindy was skipped (trial expired, $29.99 paywall). Nothing was paid.

On video

Clips from the filmed runs. Silent, so the caption under each one is the description.

  • All agents on the holiday return task
  • Grok builds the comparison table and picks Amazon
  • Manus thinks, then shows a connection error

Results

Grok met 8 of 8 with 0 factual errors and takes 2 points. ChatGPT and Genspark each met 7 of 8 and take 1 point. ChatGPT has 1 factual error and Genspark has 2, so ChatGPT ranks ahead on errors, then on time (about 1.1 minutes to about 3.6). Manus met 0 of 8, takes 0 points, and has 0 factual errors, because there was no answer. A checklist miss is an item the task asked for that the answer did not meet. A factual error is a specific claim stated as fact that we checked and found wrong. Manus missed all 8 items and still has 0 factual errors. Those are not the same count. Genspark’s Amazon gift-refund claim is a factual error and is not an extra checklist miss. Lindy was skipped and is not in this table.

Shootout #5 holiday gift return results, ranked by points, then items met, then fewest factual errors, then time. Grok passed 8/8 with 0 factual errors. Lindy was skipped and is not in this table.
RankAgentResultPtsItemsTimeInterventionsCostPlan
1GrokHeavyPass28/8 · 0 factual errors~1 min0$0SuperGrok
2ChatGPT agentWork (GPT-6.1 Sol, Light)Partial17/8 · 1 factual error~1.1 min1$0ChatGPT Plus
3GensparkSuper Agent, Standard (free)Partial17/8 · 2 factual errors~3.6 min0$0Free
4Manus2.0 Lite (free)Fail00/8 · 0 factual errors~10 sec1$0Free

Skipped

A skipped run is not a score. It is not a fail, and it is not in the pass-rate count.

  • Lindy

    Skipped: trial expired, $29.99 paywall. Free trial expired. Lindy asked for the $29.99 plan. Nothing paid. Recorded as 0 runs, not a scored run.

Notes

The count in the items column sits beside each score. The lines under a score are that run’s factual errors. Grok has 0. ChatGPT has 1. Genspark has 2. Manus has 0. A checklist miss is different from a wrong fact: a miss is an item left unmet, and a factual error is a claim we checked and found wrong.

  • Grok

    Every window, holiday date, exception, and fee is right, with an official link for each retailer. Pick: Amazon, returnable through Jan 31, 2027. First win. Run

    0 factual errors

  • ChatGPT agent

    Every date is right. Pick: Walmart with a gift receipt, returnable through Jan 31, 2027, the best pick of the round. Item 5 is missed because the Best Buy gift-return rule is wrong. The operator aborted a first attempt where the prompt was split into separate messages. The clean single-message rerun is the scored run. That abort is the 1 intervention. Run

    • Said Best Buy's policy page omits separate gift-return refund terms; the page says in-store gift returns get store credit and mailed gift returns credit the buyer.
  • Genspark

    The most thorough answer, quoting policy text. Pick: Amazon, returnable through Jan 31, 2027. Item 6 is missed because it said Target charges no restocking fee. The Amazon gift-refund claim is a second factual error and is not a second checklist miss. Best Buy membership prices ($29.99 Plus, $199.99 Total) check out. Run

    • Said Target charges no restocking fee; Target charges up to $35 on opened phones.
    • Said Amazon gift returns get money back rather than store credit; Amazon refunds gift returns to an Amazon gift card balance.
  • Manus

    Showed “Manus is thinking” for about 10 seconds, then “Check your internet connection and try again.” No answer. One Retry click did nothing, and other sites worked on the same connection. All 8 items are missed. There is no factual error, because there was no claim to check. This is a fail, not a skip. Run

    0 factual errors

Checklist

Eight items, same list for every agent who ran. Missed does not count as met. The count beside the checklist score is separate: a factual error is a claim we checked and found wrong, and a missing or wrong checklist item stays a checklist miss. Lindy has no checklist, because it was skipped. How we score.

Per-agent checklist for the four scored runs. Each cell is Met or Missed.
ItemGrokChatGPT agentGensparkManus
Standard return windowsMetMetMetMissed
2026 holiday purchase datesMetMetMetMissed
Last holiday return dateMetMetMetMissed
Electronics and Apple windowsMetMetMetMissed
Gift-recipient refund rulesMetMissedMetMissed
Restocking fees and membershipsMetMetMissedMissed
Official policy linksMetMetMetMissed
Comparison table and pickMetMetMetMissed

Judgment calls

  • Amazon and Walmart are both correct picks. A non-Apple laptop bought in November 2026 is returnable at either through Jan 31, 2027. Walmart edges Amazon for a gift recipient: a gift-receipt return can be exchanged, put on a Walmart gift card, or credited to the sender’s original payment. An Amazon recipient gets Amazon gift-card balance and cannot exchange. Best Buy’s standard holiday deadline is Jan 15, 2027, which is the last day of mid-January and the trap. Nobody picked Best Buy.
  • Full credit for Walmart or Amazon when the answer gives the Jan 31, 2027 reason. Partial credit for Costco if the answer explains the 90-day-from-receipt window and the membership or receipt catch, or for Target. Wrong: Best Buy as the best choice, a Costco holiday extension, or a Jan 31 deadline for Target electronics.
  • ChatGPT’s item 5 is missed, and that same claim is its 1 factual error. It said Best Buy’s policy page omits separate gift-return refund terms. The page says an in-store gift return gets store credit, and a mailed gift return credits the buyer.
  • ChatGPT’s first attempt was aborted by the operator because the prompt was split into separate messages. The clean single-message run is the one scored. That abort is recorded as 1 intervention. ChatGPT’s Amazon links point at an Amazon help subdomain (digprjsurvey.amazon.com), which loads.
  • Genspark’s item 6 is missed because it said Target charges no restocking fee. Target charges up to $35 on opened phones. That claim is also a factual error.
  • Genspark’s second factual error is separate from the checklist. It said Amazon gift returns get money back rather than store credit. Amazon refunds a gift return to an Amazon gift card balance. Item 5 stayed met. The two misses and the two wrong facts are not the same list.
  • Genspark’s Best Buy membership prices, $29.99 for Plus and $199.99 for Total, check out.
  • Manus showed “Manus is thinking” for about 10 seconds, then “Check your internet connection and try again.” There was no answer. One Retry click did nothing. Other sites worked on the same connection. All 8 checklist items are missed. Factual errors stay at 0, because a missing answer is not a wrong claim. That is a fail, not a skip, and it is in the pass-rate denominator.
  • Saying Costco’s US gift-recipient rules are not published is correct. No official US page states them. Inventing a US gift rule would be a factual error. Costco has no 2026 holiday extension. The newest official wording found is the policy page published Oct 2, 2025, and the 90-day electronics window is not extended.
  • Lindy was skipped: the free trial had expired, and Lindy asked for the $29.99 plan. Nothing was paid. That is 0 runs, not a fail. It is not a scored run, and it is not in the denominator. Same treatment as Shootout #3 and Shootout #4.
  • Grok was last on Shootout #1 and Shootout #2. This is its first win.
  • Times are measured from the screen recording, from send to a finished answer. The spend cap is $0 extra. Contacting a business, creating an account, or buying anything is an automatic fail. Nobody did.

Ground truth

Checked Nov 10, 2026 against each retailer’s official US return-policy page. A non-Apple laptop sold by the retailer, in new or like-new condition, with the recipient holding a gift receipt or order number.

  • Amazon: 30 days from delivery. Holiday purchases Nov 1–Dec 31, 2026 return through Jan 31, 2027. Apple-branded products return through Jan 15, 2027, and new Apple products otherwise get 15 days. Laptops and TVs follow the standard 30 days. A gift recipient’s refund goes to their Amazon.com gift card balance. The 100% restocking fee applies to opened software, video games, and collectibles. The page lists no Prime-specific return window. Policy.
  • Walmart: 90 days (Marketplace sellers, 30). Holiday purchases Oct 1–Dec 31, 2026 return through Jan 31, 2027. Consumer electronics and PCs are 30 days and are not on the holiday exception list, so a November laptop qualifies. A gift receipt can be exchanged, refunded to a Walmart gift card, or credited to the sender’s original payment. No receipt: exchange or a Walmart gift card. No restocking fee on Walmart-sold items. Some Marketplace sellers charge up to 20%. Walmart+ adds home pickup, not extra days. Policy.
  • Target: 90 days for most unopened items. Holiday purchases Nov 1–Dec 24, 2026. Electronics and entertainment are due Jan 24, 2027. Apple, Beats, and phones are due Jan 8, 2027. Outside the holiday window, electronics are 30 days and Apple and Beats are 14. A gift receipt or packing slip refunds to a Target GiftCard. Without one, the recipient may get a merchandise return card. Opened phones carry a restocking fee of up to $35. Target Circle Card holders and Circle 360 members get an extra 30 days. Policy.
  • Best Buy: 15 days, or 60 days for My Best Buy Plus and Total. Holiday purchases Oct 30–Dec 31, 2026 return through Jan 15, 2027. Plus and Total members: purchases Oct 30–Dec 3, 2026 return through Jan 31, 2027, and purchases on or after Dec 4 get 60 days. Laptops, TVs, and Apple products have no separate window. An in-store gift return gets store credit. A mailed gift return credits the purchaser. Activatable devices cost $45 to return. No restocking fee is listed for a laptop. Policy.
  • Costco: most merchandise has no stated time limit, with limitations. There is no 2026 holiday extension. Computers, TVs, tablets, major appliances, and phones are 90 days from the day the member received them, and that window is not extended. US gift-recipient, no-receipt, and non-member rules are not published. No restocking fee is stated. The membership fee can be refunded at any time. Policy.
  • For the laptop, Amazon and Walmart both run through Jan 31, 2027, about two weeks past mid-January, with no laptop restocking fee. Target runs to Jan 24. A standard Best Buy customer is on the last day, Jan 15. Costco’s 90 days from receipt can reach February for most November dates, but it needs Costco’s purchase record or a membership, and the US gift rules are not published.

Findings

  • Grok is the only 8/8, with 0 factual errors, in about 1 minute. First win. It picked Amazon through Jan 31, 2027.
  • Walmart with a gift receipt is the sharper pick, and ChatGPT made it. The Best Buy gift-return rule is the claim that kept ChatGPT at 7/8.
  • Genspark quoted the most policy text and still missed Target’s phone restocking fee and Amazon’s gift-card refund.
  • Manus produced no answer. The connection error is a fail with 0 factual errors, not a skipped run.
  • No scored agent contacted a retailer, created an account, or spent money. Lindy never started.

The prompt

This is the whole brief. No agent gets a rewrite.

I'm buying holiday gifts in November 2026 and want to know how long the people I give them to will have to return them. Using each retailer's official return policy pages, compare Amazon, Walmart, Target, Best Buy and Costco (all US).

For each retailer include:
1. The standard return window for most items
2. The 2026 holiday return policy: which purchase dates qualify and the last day to return
3. The shorter window or special rules for electronics, such as a laptop, TV or Apple product
4. Whether a gift recipient can return an item without the buyer's receipt (gift receipt or other option) and how they get refunded
5. Any restocking fees or membership-based differences in the return rules
6. A direct link to the official return policy page

Then put everything in one comparison table and tell me which retailer is the best place to buy a $300 laptop as a gift that might be returned in mid-January 2027.

Rules: do not contact any business, do not create accounts, and do not buy anything.

Pass checklist

The list used to score the runs on Nov 10, 2026. Pass means every item below is met. The same list grades every agent. A checklist miss is an item not met. A factual error is counted separately, beside the score.

  1. All 5 retailers are covered, and the standard return window is correct for each.
  2. The 2026 holiday purchase-date range is correct for each retailer that has one, or the answer correctly says there is none.
  3. The final holiday return date is correct for each retailer.
  4. Electronics, Apple, and laptop exception windows are correct.
  5. Gift-recipient return rules are accurate: gift receipt or no receipt, and the form of the refund.
  6. Restocking fees and membership-tier differences are accurate.
  7. A direct official return-policy link is given for each retailer.
  8. One comparison table, plus a sensible and correct pick for a $300 laptop returned in mid-January 2027.

Judgment rules

  • Windows, dates, fees, and gift rules are checked against the retailer’s official US return-policy page on Nov 10, 2026.
  • A wrong stated window, date, fee, or refund rule is a factual error. Leaving an item unmet is a checklist miss. One does not replace the other.
  • Amazon and Walmart both earn the pick when the Jan 31, 2027 deadline is the reason. Best Buy as the best place for a mid-January return does not.
  • “Not published” is correct for Costco’s US gift-recipient rules. A made-up US gift rule is a factual error.
  • One intervention is allowed without penalty, such as a sign-in cleared to start the agent itself. It is recorded, not scored. Aborting a split-prompt attempt and scoring the clean rerun is recorded. A connection error that ends the run with no answer is a fail, not a skip.
  • Agents never contact a retailer, create an account, or buy anything. Spend cap is $0 extra. Time cap is 30 minutes. Contacting a business, creating an account, or spending money is an automatic fail.

Partial and fail

Same point values as Shootout #1, Shootout #2, Shootout #3, and Shootout #4. These cutoffs were the scoring rules for this task.

Pass · 2
All 8 items are met.
Partial · 1
5 to 7 items are met.
Fail · 0
4 or fewer items are met. Contacting a business, creating an account, or buying anything is also an automatic fail.

Rank is points, then items met, then fewest factual errors, then time. A run that was skipped is not ranked and scores no points.

Full scoring rulesShootout #1Shootout #2Shootout #3Shootout #4Shootout #6Shootout #7Shootout #8Back to the board