Skip to content

Shootout #4Results in

Renew an adult US passport by mail

Raleigh, NC 27601. The passport was issued in 2017, is undamaged, and is in the current name. It expires in 4 months, and the trip is in 10 weeks. Three agents scored, same prompt, Nov 6, 2026. Ranked by points, then items met, then fewest factual errors, then time. Every scored run cost $0 extra and needed 0 interventions. Manus was skipped (login expired). Lindy was skipped (trial expired, $29.99 paywall). Nothing was paid.

On video

Clips from the filmed runs. Silent, so the caption under each one is the description.

  • All agents on the passport task
  • ChatGPT agent writes the winning guide
  • Genspark sends NC renewals to the wrong PO boxes

Results

ChatGPT and Grok each met 8 of 8 with 0 factual errors and take 2 points. That is a tie on the checklist and on errors. ChatGPT is first on time, about 1.4 minutes to about 1.5. Genspark met 6 of 8, takes 1 point, and has 3 factual errors. The one-line descriptions sit with that score below. A checklist miss is an item the task asked for that the answer did not meet. A factual error is a specific claim stated as fact that we checked and found wrong. Genspark missed the expedite and return-delivery claim, and both mailing addresses. Those two misses are not the same thing as its 3 wrong facts. The prompt asked for a 1-2 day return fee. The official return option is 1-3 day delivery for $26.87. ChatGPT and Grok saying 1-3 day is correct, and it is not an error. Manus and Lindy were skipped and are not in this table.

Shootout #4 passport renewal results, ranked by points, then items met, then fewest factual errors, then time. ChatGPT and Grok tied at 8/8 with 0 factual errors; ChatGPT is first on time. Manus and Lindy were skipped and are not in this table.
RankAgentResultPtsItemsTimeInterventionsCostPlan
1ChatGPT agentWork (GPT-6.1 Sol, Light)Pass28/8 · 0 factual errors~1.4 min0$0ChatGPT Plus
2GrokHeavyPass28/8 · 0 factual errors~1.5 min0$0SuperGrok
3GensparkStandard (free)Partial16/8 · 3 factual errors~3.5 min0$0Free

Skipped

A skipped run is not a score. It is not a fail, and it is not in the pass-rate count.

  • Manus

    Skipped: login expired. Login expired on the box browser (sign-in wall). Skipped, and no account action was taken. Recorded as 0 runs, not a scored run.

  • Lindy

    Skipped: trial expired, $29.99 paywall. Free trial expired. Lindy asked for the $29.99 plan. Nothing paid. Recorded as 0 runs, not a scored run.

Notes

The count in the items column sits beside each score. The lines under a score are that run’s factual errors. ChatGPT and Grok have 0. Genspark has 3. A checklist miss is different from a wrong fact: a miss is an item left unmet, and a factual error is a claim we checked and found wrong.

  • ChatGPT agent

    Every fee, address, and limit is correct. Pick: expedited mail renewal plus the $26.87 1-3 day return, $216.87 to PO Box 90955. It correctly flagged that the official return option is 1-3 day delivery, not the 1-2 day wording in the prompt. Links are shown as source chips. Tied with Grok at 8/8 and 0 factual errors; first on time. Run

    0 factual errors

  • Grok

    Also 8/8 with 0 factual errors. It listed full travel.state.gov URLs and the state-by-state routine address rule. Pick: expedite by mail, and strongly consider the 1-3 day return. Tied with ChatGPT on items and on errors; a hair slower, so second. Run

    0 factual errors

  • Genspark

    Fees, photo rules, and the online option are right. Both mailing addresses are wrong, so a North Carolina renewal would go to the wrong PO box. Pick: expedite, $190 to PO Box 90155. Item 3 is missed because it claimed expedited service includes return delivery. Item 5 is missed because both addresses are wrong. Run

    • Routine address given as PO Box 640155, Irving TX; that box is only for CA, FL, IL, MN, NY, TX. NC routine goes to PO Box 90155, Philadelphia.
    • Expedited address given as PO Box 90155; the expedited box is PO Box 90955, Philadelphia, PA 19190-0955.
    • Claimed expedited mail renewals include 1-2 day return delivery; return delivery is a separate $26.87 1-3 day add-on, so its $190 total skips it.

Checklist

Eight items, same list for every agent who ran. Missed does not count as met. The count beside the checklist score is separate: a factual error is a claim we checked and found wrong, and a missing or wrong checklist item stays a checklist miss. Manus and Lindy have no checklist, because they were skipped. How we score.

Per-agent checklist for the three scored runs. Each cell is Met, Missed, or Flagged.
ItemChatGPT agentGrokGenspark
Mail renewal and form DS-82MetMetMet
Book, card, and both feesMetMetMet
Expedite and return-delivery feesMetMetMissed
Check payable to StateMetMetMet
Routine and expedited addressesMetMetMissed
Processing times and expedite callMetMetMet
Photo requirementsMetMetMet
Online renewal and official linksMetMetMet

Judgment calls

  • The prompt said “1-2 day” return delivery. The official option is 1-3 day delivery for $26.87. ChatGPT and Grok saying 1-3 day is correct, not an error.
  • ChatGPT and Grok tied at 8/8 with 0 factual errors. ChatGPT is ranked first on time, about 1.4 minutes against about 1.5.
  • Genspark’s item 3 is missed because it claimed expedited mail renewal includes 1-2 day return delivery. Return delivery is a separate $26.87 1-3 day add-on. A passport book is $130 and expedited service is $60, which is the $190 total it gave, so that total skips the return fee. With the return option the total is $216.87, which is what ChatGPT sent to PO Box 90955.
  • Genspark’s item 5 is missed because both addresses are wrong. It gave the routine address as PO Box 640155, Irving, TX. That box is only for California, Florida, Illinois, Minnesota, New York, and Texas. A North Carolina routine renewal goes to National Passport Processing Center, PO Box 90155, Philadelphia, PA 19190-0155. It gave the expedited address as PO Box 90155. Expedited mail goes to National Passport Processing Center, PO Box 90955, Philadelphia, PA 19190-0955.
  • Those two checklist misses are separate from the 3 factual errors. The errors are the wrong routine box, the wrong expedited box, and the claim that expedited service includes return delivery. The misses are the checklist items those claims failed.
  • Routine processing is 4–6 weeks and expedited processing is 2–3 weeks, and mailing can take up to 2 weeks each way. For a trip in 10 weeks, expediting is the sensible call. ChatGPT and Grok both recommended it.
  • Manus was skipped: login expired on the box browser, a sign-in wall. No account action was taken. That is 0 runs, not a fail. It is not a scored run, and it is not in the denominator when passes are divided by tasks run.
  • Lindy was skipped: the free trial had expired, and Lindy asked for the $29.99 plan. Nothing was paid. That is 0 runs, not a fail. It is not a scored run, and it is not in the denominator. Same treatment as Shootout #3.

Ground truth

Checked against travel.state.gov on Nov 6, 2026: renew by mail, online renewal, get-fast and processing-time pages, and the DS-82 instructions. Those pages were last updated Sep 30, 2026.

  • Mail renewal uses form DS-82. The check is payable to “U.S. Department of State”.
  • Fees: passport book $130, passport card $30, both $160, expedite $60, and 1-3 day return delivery $26.87. The prompt’s “1-2 day” wording is the 1-3 day option.
  • North Carolina routine service: National Passport Processing Center, PO Box 90155, Philadelphia, PA 19190-0155. Expedited service: National Passport Processing Center, PO Box 90955, Philadelphia, PA 19190-0955. PO Box 640155 in Irving, TX is only for California, Florida, Illinois, Minnesota, New York, and Texas.
  • Routine processing is 4–6 weeks. Expedited processing is 2–3 weeks. Mailing can take up to 2 weeks each way.
  • Photo: 2×2 inches, white or off-white background, no glasses, taken within 6 months.
  • Online renewal is at opr.travel.state.gov. It is for applicants age 25 or older, with a 10-year passport that expires within 1 year or expired less than 5 years ago, with no information change, who are not traveling for 6 or more weeks. Online renewal is routine service only. It cannot be expedited.

Findings

  • ChatGPT and Grok both finished 8/8 with 0 factual errors. ChatGPT is first on time.
  • The official return option is 1-3 day delivery for $26.87. The prompt said 1-2 day.
  • Genspark’s packet for a North Carolina renewal would have gone to the wrong PO boxes, and its $190 total left out the return-delivery fee.
  • No scored agent contacted an agency, created an account, or spent money. Manus and Lindy never started.

The prompt

This is the whole brief. No agent gets a rewrite.

I live in Raleigh, NC 27601 and my adult US passport (issued 2017, undamaged, in my current name) expires in 4 months. I want to renew it by mail and I have an international trip in 10 weeks.

Using official sources, give me a clear step-by-step guide that includes:
1. Whether I qualify to renew by mail, and which form to use (form number and name)
2. The exact current fees for a passport book, a passport card, and both, plus the expedite fee and the 1-2 day return delivery fee
3. Who to make the check payable to
4. The mailing address for routine service and for expedited service
5. Current routine and expedited processing times, and whether I should expedite given my 10-week timeline
6. Photo requirements (size, background, glasses rule, how recent)
7. Whether I can renew online instead, and any limits on that
8. Links to the official pages you used

Do not contact, call, email, or submit anything to any business or agency. Don't create accounts or spend money. Give me the answer as a final written guide.

Pass checklist

The list used to score the runs on Nov 6, 2026. Pass means every item below is met. The same list grades every agent. A checklist miss is an item not met. A factual error is counted separately, beside the score.

  1. Eligibility for mail renewal is correct, and the form is named DS-82.
  2. Book, card, and both fees match the current fees on travel.state.gov.
  3. The expedite fee and the 1-2 day return delivery fee are correct.
  4. The check is payable to “U.S. Department of State”.
  5. The routine mailing address and the expedited mailing address are both correct.
  6. Current routine and expedited processing times are stated, and the expedite recommendation makes sense for a trip in 10 weeks.
  7. Photo requirements are correct: 2×2 inches, white or off-white background, no glasses, taken within 6 months.
  8. The online renewal option is addressed accurately, and official travel.state.gov links are cited.

Judgment rules

  • Fees, addresses, and processing times are checked against travel.state.gov and the DS-82 instructions. The pages used for this score were last updated Sep 30, 2026.
  • The prompt’s “1-2 day” return fee is scored against the official 1-3 day delivery fee of $26.87. Calling it 1-3 day is correct.
  • A wrong stated address or fee is a factual error. Leaving an item unmet is a checklist miss. One does not replace the other.
  • Routine processing of 4–6 weeks, plus mailing of up to 2 weeks each way, can use most of a 10-week window. Recommending expedited service counts as the sensible call.
  • One intervention is allowed without penalty, such as a sign-in cleared to start the agent itself. It is recorded, not scored. A login wall that stops the run before it starts is a skip, not an intervention.
  • Agents never submit a form, create an account, or enter payment details. Spend cap is $0 extra. Time cap is 30 minutes. Contacting, submitting, creating an account, or spending money is an automatic fail.

Partial and fail

Same point values as Shootout #1, Shootout #2, and Shootout #3. These cutoffs were the scoring rules for this task.

Pass · 2
All 8 items are met.
Partial · 1
5 to 7 items are met.
Fail · 0
4 or fewer items are met. Contacting or submitting anything to a business or agency, creating an account, or spending money is also an automatic fail.

Rank is points, then items met, then fewest factual errors, then time. A run that was skipped is not ranked and scores no points.

Full scoring rulesShootout #1Shootout #2Shootout #3Shootout #5Shootout #6Shootout #7Shootout #8Back to the board